Favorite Hymns

Greg Austen Avatar

Continuing my Storyworth project, here’s how I answered: What are your favorite hymns and why? In answering, I realized that the following verse is prominent in my thinking, especially the part I’ve italicized: “Nevertheless, I am continually with you. You hold my right hand.” (Psalm 73:23, NRSVUE) Although both have their place, I resonate with the objective hymns of the faith (what God has done and how he feels about me) more than the subjective (what I’ve done or how I feel about what God has done). What I mean is that I’d rather celebrate God’s right hand than my right or left. I’d rather celebrate the power of Jesus’ name—the cataclysmic, universe-altering things accomplished when Jesus said, “It is finished!”—than how much I surrender or love to tell the story. With that in mind, here are my top 15:

Holy, Holy, Holy- This may be my favorite. So much of who God is (“merciful and mighty”) and a Trinitarian theology is confessed here. The phrase “early in the morning our songs shall rise to thee” reminds me of Psalm 5:1-3a: Give ear to my words, O LORD, consider my meditation. Hearken unto the voice of my cry, my King, and my God; For unto thee will I pray. My voice shalt thou hear in the morning…” (KJV) It makes me think of my mom’s example and my practice of cultivating some devotional time with the Lord every morning. Thankfully, unlike a “daily quiet time” that I was forced to do in my earlier toxic church days, this habit is rooted in delight rather than duty and legalism, and, admittedly, an excellent cup of coffee or two enhances the experience!

A Mighty Fortress- My grandfather Seaman was a Lutheran minister, and this is Luther’s quintessential contribution to the Church’s greatest songs. It captures the heart of the Protestant Reformation and is based on Psalm 46, a psalm that this hymn helped make precious to me. Luther called music “the handmaiden of theology,” meaning it has the capacity to promotes, popularizes, and makes accessible great and accurate views of God and the Bible. This is certainly true, even of the best contemporary worship songs. As far as this hymn is concerned, however, it is rich and, like Amazing Grace, must be sung in sequence to fully appreciate how powerful it is. Pay close attention especially to the transition of “that name,” Luther’s boldness, taking the devils of the world seriously, and how it still speaks to the pervasive Christian nationalism of our day: “That word above all earthly powers. No thanks to them abideth…His kingdom is forever.”

When I Survey the Wondrous Cross- This is another rich but beautifully simplistic hymn like Amazing Grace. There’s also a great nod to the world of nature in this last verse (“were the whole realm of nature mine”), and it ends with a brief but appropriate response of commitment (“demands my soul, my life, my all”). Another fun reason I like this hymn is that my dad was a surveyor, so there’s that. BTW, surveyors are all outstanding in their field, just by nature of their work. Think about it. 😉

All Hail the Power of Jesus’ Name- again, a very high view of God, and I love the “every kindred, every tribe” verse. This song also makes me think of the end of Psalm 103: “Let angels prostrate fall.” BTW, this is very different than: ” Let angels prostates fall,” something a little confusing for some. Let the singer beware!

Crown Him with Crowns- I love the image of “the Lamb upon the throne” and the lyric “Hail him as the matchless King for all eternity.”

Oh, the Deep, Deep Love of Jesus– “The love of God is one of the greatest Christian themes I continue to mature in. Simple and lovely: “Oh, the deep, deep love of Jesus; Vast, unmeasured, boundless, free; Rolling as a mighty ocean in its fullness over me…”

The Love of God- it’s this amazing last verse: “Could we with ink the ocean fill, and were the skies of parchment made; Were every stalk on earth a quill, and every man on earth a scribe by trade; To write the love of God above would drain the ocean dry; nor could the scroll contain the whole, though stretched from sky to sky.”

Be Thou My Vision- Helen Keller observed that “the saddest thing in the world is people who can see but have no vision.” Especially in my earlier years as a youth pastor, I would often emphasize the word focus, which is related to vision. This hymn captures so much of that all-encompassing part of being “in Christ” or the immersive, mysterious part of “in him we live and move and have our being” (Acts 17:28). This: “Be thou my best thought by day or by night, waking or sleeping thy presence my light.” And then at the end: “Heart of my own heart, whatever befall; still be my vision, O ruler of all.”

Morning Has Broken- this hymn lacks explicit reference to Christ or trinitarian theology. Still, it’s a celebration of creation in the Celtic tradition, which also makes me think of the first half of Psalm 19. I love Cat Stevens’ version, and to my knowledge, this was my Grandmother Seaman’s favorite hymn.

And Can It Be?– The great preacher and founder of Methodism, John Wesley’s brother Charles, wrote this. John was jokingly called a “closet Calvinist” because of this amazing line reflecting God’s initiative in our salvation: “My chains fell off, my heart was free, I rose, went forth and followed thee.”

Amazing Grace- how could this hymn not be on anyone’s list? Again, the beauty and simplicity; it is like the John 3:16 of hymns. And when you know John Newton’s story as a former slave trader, that beauty is taken to a whole new level. I love singing the last verse a cappella.

Great Is Thy Faithfulness– this song is like the precursor to the modern “Goodness of God,” which is a favorite. Also, the writer of “Great Is Thy Faithfulness” lived in Vineland, NJ, near where I grew up.

Come, Thou Fount of Every Blessing– “Prone to wander, Lord, I feel it.” Again, how can you improve this? This signature phrase captures both my experience as a Christian and how I feel most of the time when I show up at church for corporate worship.

O God, Our Help in Ages Past- this song makes me think of the “great cloud of witnesses” in Hebrews 11 that we are, in some sense, “surrounded by” from the past. There’s a lot of encouragement in reading church history and hearing stories of how people struggled with adverse circumstances, sin, and failure, just like we do. Plus, there is often the reminder that what they went through was a whole lot worse.

It Is Well With My Soul– again, so powerful when you know the story behind this hymn– the man who lost his family. Again, how could a lyric like this be improved upon? “Let this blessed assurance control: that Christ hath regarded my helpless estate and hath shed his own blood for my soul.” What a strong declaration of faith.

Well, there’s my fifteen, although “Praise to the Lord, the Almighty” and “Joyful, Joyful We Adore” deserve an honorable mention. Also, having read her biography as a young boy, I like many of Fanny Crosby’s hymns (e.g., “Blessed Assurance”). My fundamentalist, Baptist upbringing, however, tainted or trivialized some of hers and others for me. So many of the songs were sing-songy and now remind me of silly or merry-go-round music (e.g., Beulah Land). I remember one pianist mom and I used to call “Amazing Grace” (her name really was Grace) because she played the piano so fast we often felt like we were off to the races! Their own shortcomings aside, I have to give the Presbyterians some credit for introducing me to better theology and hymns in my early 20s.